What do the ban on watermelon in Rio Claro and the regulation of dog barking in Penha have in common? Discover how to formulate effective and realistic regulations without neglecting technical, social, and legal aspects.

Throughout Brazilian legislative history, several examples have drawn attention for the creativity of its legislators, not always in a positive way.

In Rio Claro (SP), for example, a law from the end of the 19th century prohibited the sale and consumption of watermelon, based on the belief that the fruit transmitted yellow fever.

In Bocaiúva do Sul (PR), a municipal regulation went further, prohibiting the sale and distribution of condoms, with the aim of encouraging the local birth rate.

These examples illustrate how a lack of technical and social reflection in the legislative process can result in ineffective regulations that are out of touch with reality.

Furthermore, there are laws that, although well-intentioned, end up presenting curious aspects, such as the one in Pouso Alegre (MG), which provides for a fine for written communication with errors in grammar, government, or spelling. Although it is a concern for the Portuguese language, the practical enforceability of such a rule raises questions.

Another example is the federal regulation from the 1960s that stipulated that horse races could only take place on Sundays and holidays, perhaps guaranteeing the animals rest on the other days of the week.

These episodes highlight the importance of a legislative process grounded in technical criteria, reasonableness, and impact assessment, in order to avoid social or legal challenges.

A poorly drafted law can result in regulatory uncertainty, unnecessary public spending, and damage public confidence in the legislative process.

Recently, a symbolic example of a legislative error was recorded in Penha (SC), where the City Council approved a law limiting the hours during which dogs could bark, seeking to regulate noise pollution. The proposal was interpreted by many as disproportionate and impractical. Faced with the backlash, the author of the bill stated that there had been a "misunderstanding," but the damage to his public image had already been done.

This episode, although municipal in scope, serves as a warning to all levels of the legislature: the gap between political intent and the appropriate formulation of regulations should not be underestimated.

Why is a legislative drafting checklist essential for those working in the legislature?

Draft laws with formal flaws or lack of technical precision compromise the effectiveness of the legislation and public trust in the legislative process. To ensure the creation of efficient and responsible laws, it is essential to use practical tools, such as the Law Drafting Checklist.

This checklist, developed from contemporary discussions addressed in the IDP's postgraduate program in Legislative Law , serves as a "legislative quality filter," ensuring that proposals meet essential technical and social requirements.

Among the points that the checklist addresses are:

• Mastery of legislative technique (Legal Studies I and II).
• Strict adherence to due legislative process. and to the internal regulations.
• A systemic view of the stages of the legislative process., with judicial review of constitutionality.
• Assessment of political, social, economic and budgetary impacts..

The contemporary legislature plays a central role in the democratic system, serving as a crucial space for the strategic formulation of public policies, conflict mediation, and impact assessment. Each approved law has the power to legitimately transform social reality.

Based on this perspective, the Postgraduate Program in Legislative Law at IDP offers training that combines technical rigor, a systemic vision, and an interdisciplinary approach. This allows legislative professionals to act in a qualified manner, creating norms that respond to the needs of society and promote legal certainty.

The Legislative Drafting Checklist is a useful tool for ensuring legislative quality and the effectiveness of public policies. When incorporated into the legislative process, it strengthens the commitment to legal certainty and the effectiveness of approved laws.

Fill out the form below and access the Law Drafting Checklist now.

[hubspot type=”form” portal=”8880856″ id=”7cc4fe0f-1f36-4cd7-8e45-2f82bc1b5d6e”]